Magic vs Muggle: Journalism, Education, + More!


JK Rowling created a very detailed and well-plotted story. Yet how come Hogwarts’ students miss out on traditional problem solving and critical thinking lessons? Are most wizards idiots?

hogwarts stained glass

Jada an officer of Geek Girl Brunch and Julia of our future Lost rewatch podcast episodes suggested we discuss more philosophical issues in Harry Potter. Like how the media works in the wizarding world and what aspects of the muggle world do Wizards actually care about and/or get involved in.

Magic vs Muggle Media:

magic muggle

We know about The Daily Prophet and the Quibbler but are those the only news publications the Wizarding World has? What does it mean that The Daily Prophet’s offices are within the Ministry of Magic’s offices? Is it ever a good idea to have some control over the media or should it always be transparent and unbiased?

Magic vs Muggle Education:

It appears that wizards don’t get a chance to learn critical thinking skills. What’s up with that? Are we missing something? Is that why it’s so easy for them to take one source of journalism as the word on what’s going on in the world?

seamus finnegan potions class magic vs muggle

Perhaps this is JK Rowling’s commentary on the world. Most of the world isn’t like Hermione, proactive, objective, and observant.

hermione library magic vs muggle

This has been one of my favorite Potterweek records so far. Listen in and let us know what you think!

Enjoyed this episode and want to be on a Potterweek ep? Just hit us up in the comments, on social media, or at!!

Check out our Potterweek posts here:

7/25 Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone movie commentary with Megan Gotch aka The Nerdy Girlie and Katie Elhoffer of Elhoffer Designs. Big kudos to our podcasting intern Kristen!

7/26 Hermione: Our Favorite Know it All GirlBoss with Amanda of Great Beer Adventure!

7/27 The Dursleys: A Look at Harry’s Only Living Family Members with Kris of No Extra Words!

7/28 Relationships in Potter: Ginny + Harry, Snape/Lily/James with Alice of Girl Who Roams and Kayla of Epicfied!

7/29 Villains in Potter with Akua and Ashley both officers of Geek Girl Brunch NYC. Also of A Stylish Jedi and You Haven’t Seen respectively.

7/31 Religion in Potter with Stefani and James (my friends from work!).